Brooks B17 S Women's Saddle
The Brooks B17 S Women's Saddle is a best-in-class leather option known for its long-term durability and wide, anatomic profile that suits the upright riding positions common on many electric bikes. It earns its place by delivering unmatched longevity and tailored comfort after break-in, offering a lower lifetime cost compared with cheaper saddles; compared with the Cambium it trades weatherproof convenience for classic leather support, and versus the Anatomica it prioritizes broad load-bearing stability over aggressive cutaway pressure relief.
Molds to you
Enduring leather patina
Molds to you
Enduring leather patina
Review Summary
"Reviewers who used the Brooks B17 S Women's saddle for long distances praise its classic leather construction and lasting comfort after a substantial break-in period, while noting it is heavy and initially stiff for some riders."
Long-haul throne
Full-grain leather top that breaks in and molds to the rider for personalized long-ride comfort.
Long-haul throne
Full-grain leather top that breaks in and molds to the rider for personalized long-ride comfort.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Recreational Enjoyment
The Brooks B17 S Women's Saddle is a best-in-class leather option known for its long-term durability and wide, anatomic profile that suits the upright riding positions common on many electric bikes. It earns its place by delivering unmatched longevity and tailored comfort after break-in, offering a lower lifetime cost compared with cheaper saddles; compared with the Cambium it trades weatherproof convenience for classic leather support, and versus the Anatomica it prioritizes broad load-bearing stability over aggressive cutaway pressure relief.
Molds to you
Enduring leather patina
Long-haul throne
Full-grain leather top that breaks in and molds to the rider for personalized long-ride comfort.
Women-specific B17 S shape with slightly wider nose and supportive sit-bone platform suited for e-bike commuting and touring.
Molds to you
Enduring leather patina
Long-haul throne
Full-grain leather top that breaks in and molds to the rider for personalized long-ride comfort.
Women-specific B17 S shape with slightly wider nose and supportive sit-bone platform suited for e-bike commuting and touring.
$260-320 USD
Selle Anatomica X2 Flex Fly Women's
The Selle Anatomica X2 Flex Fly Women's saddle is a technical leader for riders who need real pressure relief on longer assisted rides, thanks to its flexible slotted leather and minimal foam design that prevents numbness on e-bike commutes. It stands out against the Brooks leather classics by delivering immediate anatomic relief with less break-in, and while it can cost more up-front, its ergonomic benefits can reduce discomfort-related costs and downtime for frequent electric-bike use.
Flexible comfort cradle
Pressure-relief channel
Flexible comfort cradle
Pressure-relief channel
Review Summary
"Long-term users of the Selle Anatomica X2 Flex Fly Women's report exceptional comfort and pressure relief once the leather settles, calling it a high-end, anatomically friendly saddle for long rides despite a premium price."
Freedom-to-pedal
Premium leather anatomic shell with a flexible design that allows lateral movement and pressure relief on long rides.
Freedom-to-pedal
Premium leather anatomic shell with a flexible design that allows lateral movement and pressure relief on long rides.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Recreational Enjoyment
The Selle Anatomica X2 Flex Fly Women's saddle is a technical leader for riders who need real pressure relief on longer assisted rides, thanks to its flexible slotted leather and minimal foam design that prevents numbness on e-bike commutes. It stands out against the Brooks leather classics by delivering immediate anatomic relief with less break-in, and while it can cost more up-front, its ergonomic benefits can reduce discomfort-related costs and downtime for frequent electric-bike use.
Flexible comfort cradle
Pressure-relief channel
Freedom-to-pedal
Premium leather anatomic shell with a flexible design that allows lateral movement and pressure relief on long rides.
Central open channel/cutout to reduce perineal pressure, especially useful for upright e-bike riding positions.
Flexible comfort cradle
Pressure-relief channel
Freedom-to-pedal
Premium leather anatomic shell with a flexible design that allows lateral movement and pressure relief on long rides.
Central open channel/cutout to reduce perineal pressure, especially useful for upright e-bike riding positions.
$330-420 USD
Brooks Flyer S Special Women's Saddle
The Brooks Flyer S Special Women's saddle is positioned as the market leader for touring and cargo-capable e-bikes, offering a beefed-up leather platform and reinforced construction to handle heavier loads and sustained powered riding. It complements the B17 S by prioritizing structural support and stability for loaded e-bike use—providing a middle ground between the classic B17's longevity and the Anatomica's pressure-focused ergonomics—making it a strong financial choice for commuters who need a robust, long-lasting saddle.
Cargo-ready padding
Supportive touring shape
Cargo-ready padding
Supportive touring shape
Review Summary
"Owners of the Brooks Flyer S Special Women's saddle appreciate its supportive, durable leather design for commuting and e-bike touring after break-in, though a minority find the shape less ideal for shorter riders or those seeking a softer feel."
Handles heavy loads
Wider, long-support leather platform designed for stability and comfort under heavier loads typical of e-bike touring.
Handles heavy loads
Wider, long-support leather platform designed for stability and comfort under heavier loads typical of e-bike touring.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Time-Saving Convenience
The Brooks Flyer S Special Women's saddle is positioned as the market leader for touring and cargo-capable e-bikes, offering a beefed-up leather platform and reinforced construction to handle heavier loads and sustained powered riding. It complements the B17 S by prioritizing structural support and stability for loaded e-bike use—providing a middle ground between the classic B17's longevity and the Anatomica's pressure-focused ergonomics—making it a strong financial choice for commuters who need a robust, long-lasting saddle.
Cargo-ready padding
Supportive touring shape
Handles heavy loads
Wider, long-support leather platform designed for stability and comfort under heavier loads typical of e-bike touring.
Robust construction with reinforced edges and durable rails to withstand frequent use and cargo weight.
Cargo-ready padding
Supportive touring shape
Handles heavy loads
Wider, long-support leather platform designed for stability and comfort under heavier loads typical of e-bike touring.
Robust construction with reinforced edges and durable rails to withstand frequent use and cargo weight.
$270-350 USD
Rivet Pearl Saddle
The Rivet Pearl Saddle is the value-oriented leather-style option for riders seeking an anatomic profile on electric bikes without the premium price tag; it typically uses more affordable materials and simpler construction to keep cost down. While it doesn't match the longevity or refined fit of Brooks or the targeted pressure relief of Selle Anatomica, its financial advantage is clear for buyers wanting leather aesthetics and immediate comfort on short to moderate e-bike trips.
Plush cruiser comfort
Wide supportive platform
Plush cruiser comfort
Wide supportive platform
Review Summary
"Buyers of the Rivet Pearl saddle like its immediate padded comfort and value for casual e-bike and city riding, but many report durability and finish issues over extended use compared with premium leather models."
Cloud-like sit
Leather-covered or leather-look top delivering classic styling at a more affordable price point.
Cloud-like sit
Leather-covered or leather-look top delivering classic styling at a more affordable price point.
Recreational Enjoyment
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
The Rivet Pearl Saddle is the value-oriented leather-style option for riders seeking an anatomic profile on electric bikes without the premium price tag; it typically uses more affordable materials and simpler construction to keep cost down. While it doesn't match the longevity or refined fit of Brooks or the targeted pressure relief of Selle Anatomica, its financial advantage is clear for buyers wanting leather aesthetics and immediate comfort on short to moderate e-bike trips.
Plush cruiser comfort
Wide supportive platform
Cloud-like sit
Leather-covered or leather-look top delivering classic styling at a more affordable price point.
Women's-specific ergonomic shaping and moderate padding for everyday e-bike commuting comfort.
Plush cruiser comfort
Wide supportive platform
Cloud-like sit
Leather-covered or leather-look top delivering classic styling at a more affordable price point.
Women's-specific ergonomic shaping and moderate padding for everyday e-bike commuting comfort.
$110-160 USD
Brooks Cambium C17 S Women's Saddle
The Brooks Cambium C17 S Women's Saddle is an intentionally different offering in this list—its vulcanized rubber and organic-cotton top provide a weatherproof, maintenance-free alternative to leather that is immediately comfortable for electric-bike riders. It holds a unique position by removing break-in risk and performing reliably in wet, urban e-bike conditions; financially it can save time and replacement leather care costs, though it lacks the vintage leather patina and the long-term molding benefits of the Brooks leather models.
Rain-ready rubber
Zero break-in time
Rain-ready rubber
Zero break-in time
Review Summary
"Users of the Brooks Cambium C17 S Women's saddle commonly praise its weatherproof, flexible rubber construction for comfortable, maintenance-free riding on e-bikes, with some saying it feels firmer than leather but consistently reliable."
Maintenance-free ride
Vulcanized rubber and organic-fabric top (not traditional leather) that offers leather-like comfort with full weather resistance.
Maintenance-free ride
Vulcanized rubber and organic-fabric top (not traditional leather) that offers leather-like comfort with full weather resistance.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Eco-Friendly Living
Time-Saving Convenience
The Brooks Cambium C17 S Women's Saddle is an intentionally different offering in this list—its vulcanized rubber and organic-cotton top provide a weatherproof, maintenance-free alternative to leather that is immediately comfortable for electric-bike riders. It holds a unique position by removing break-in risk and performing reliably in wet, urban e-bike conditions; financially it can save time and replacement leather care costs, though it lacks the vintage leather patina and the long-term molding benefits of the Brooks leather models.
Rain-ready rubber
Zero break-in time
Maintenance-free ride
Vulcanized rubber and organic-fabric top (not traditional leather) that offers leather-like comfort with full weather resistance.
Flexible construction that requires no break-in and stays low-maintenance—ideal for year-round e-bike use.
Rain-ready rubber
Zero break-in time
Maintenance-free ride
Vulcanized rubber and organic-fabric top (not traditional leather) that offers leather-like comfort with full weather resistance.
Flexible construction that requires no break-in and stays low-maintenance—ideal for year-round e-bike use.
$180-240 USD