Top 5 Crickets for Reptile & Amphibian Feeding in the United States (2025) — Expert-Recommended Picks for Size, Gut-Loading & Reliable Delivery

Fluker's Live Crickets are a long-established, widely distributed option prized for consistent sizing and value for everyday reptile and amphibian feeding. They hold their position as a market leader for affordability and retail availability, making them a practical choice compared with niche suppliers like Josh's Frogs or Timberline that emphasize higher survivability and specialized husbandry. For keepers balancing cost and convenience, Fluker's offers predictable inventory and easy access without the premium shipping or boutique care of the smaller brands.

Josh's Frogs Live Banded Crickets are positioned for hobbyists who prioritize health, careful husbandry, and species-appropriate gut-loading; their banded strain and hands-on rearing produce robust feeders with lower mortality than many mass-market crickets. They command a premium compared with big-box options like PetSmart or Fluker's, but that higher upfront cost is offset by better survivability and nutrition — especially important for delicate amphibians and high-value reptiles. Compared to Timberline and Reptile Deli, Josh's Frogs emphasizes education and detailed care recommendations, making them a top choice for keepers seeking consistent, high-quality feeders.

Timberline Live Crickets are known for professional-grade breeding and high survivability aimed at serious hobbyists and institutions that require reliable bulk shipments and size grading. Timberline competes with Josh's Frogs on quality but often differentiates itself with scalability and reduced overall cost-per-fed-animal due to lower mortality — a financial advantage for breeders or multi-animal collections. While Timberline is pricier than retail convenience options like PetSmart or Fluker's, their technical focus on breeding protocols and shipping reduces losses and variability for critical feeding programs.

PetSmart Live House Crickets are the most accessible option for impulse purchases and local replacement feedings, offering immediate availability through national retail stores. They are typically the most convenient and sometimes the lowest short-term cost, but quality and survivability can be inconsistent compared with specialist suppliers such as Josh's Frogs, Timberline, or Reptile Deli, which offer better husbandry and shipping care. For hobbyists needing emergency or small-quantity feeds, PetSmart is practical, but for long-term nutrition and low mortality, specialist suppliers usually deliver better value.