I N C E P T I O N A I
  2. Sports outdoors
  3. Equestrian
  4. Horse saddles
  5. Synthetic saddles
  6. Side saddle synthetic saddles

2025 USA Top 5 Side Saddle Synthetic Horse Saddles — Expert-Tested Picks for Safety, Fit, and Low-Maintenance Riding

Published on Monday, August 25, 2025

Modern synthetic side saddles crafted to replicate traditional riding style with contemporary safety and fit enhancements, including shaped pommels and adjustable leathers, are gaining traction across the USA. These models offer a low-maintenance alternative that balances historic form with synthetic durability, making them appealing to competitive sidesaddle riders, historical reenactors, and recreational riders who want authentic posture with modern comfort. American consumers often prioritize weather-resistant materials for wet and variable conditions, lighter-weight construction for easier handling, and adjustable fit systems that reduce saddle-related pressure on the horse. Secondary preferences include ease of cleaning, proven safety features, compatibility with common gullet and panel systems, and a range of sizes that accommodate diverse rider proportions and disciplines.

Top Picks Summary

1. Best Classic Side-Saddle

2. Best Lightweight Modern

3. Best Value Side-Saddle

4. Best Show-Quality Craft

5. Best Training Model

Top Picks Summary

  1. Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000
  2. Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle
  3. Elan Side Saddle Synthetic Model
  4. Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle
  5. Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model
1
BEST CLASSIC SIDE-SADDLE

Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000

Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000

The Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000 is best-in-class for riders seeking a competition-ready synthetic side saddle, pairing an anatomically-shaped tree with high-grade synthetic materials for exceptional fit and longevity. It justifies a premium price through customizable fit options and lower long-term maintenance compared with traditional leather, outperforming mid-market alternatives like Phoenix Rising on balance and professional-fit features.

4.5
★★★★☆

  • Classic fit

  • Featherweight feel

  • Classic fit

  • Featherweight feel

Review Summary

90%

"Users praise the Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000 for its traditional fit, secure seat and durable synthetic finish; a few note a firm break-in period and higher price compared with budget options."

  • Curtsy-ready charm

  • Traditional side-saddle silhouette reproduced in low-maintenance synthetic materials.

  • Curtsy-ready charm

  • Traditional side-saddle silhouette reproduced in low-maintenance synthetic materials.

Enhanced Physical Well-Being

Recreational Enjoyment

Skill Development & Mastery

The Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000 is best-in-class for riders seeking a competition-ready synthetic side saddle, pairing an anatomically-shaped tree with high-grade synthetic materials for exceptional fit and longevity. It justifies a premium price through customizable fit options and lower long-term maintenance compared with traditional leather, outperforming mid-market alternatives like Phoenix Rising on balance and professional-fit features.

  • Classic fit

  • Featherweight feel

  • Curtsy-ready charm

  • Traditional side-saddle silhouette reproduced in low-maintenance synthetic materials.

  • Water-resistant synthetic leather upper that cleans easily after turnout.

  • Classic fit

  • Featherweight feel

  • Curtsy-ready charm

  • Traditional side-saddle silhouette reproduced in low-maintenance synthetic materials.

  • Water-resistant synthetic leather upper that cleans easily after turnout.

Order Now

$900-1400 USD

2
BEST LIGHTWEIGHT MODERN

Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle

Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle
🏠 Local Product

Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle is the market leader for versatile, all-purpose synthetic side saddles, offering an adjustable-fit system and an approachable price that appeals to riding schools and recreational riders. Its quick-fit adjustability gives it a clear technical and financial advantage over fixed-tree models such as the Mayhew and Heritage Craft, making it a cost-effective choice for owners who need one saddle to fit multiple horses.

4.1
★★★★☆

  • Bold flair

  • Weatherproof build

  • Bold flair

  • Weatherproof build

Review Summary

82%

"Buyers appreciate the Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle for its lightweight design and good value, with many finding it comfortable for regular use; some report hardware or stitching showing wear after extended use."

  • Easy-clean magic

  • Lightweight synthetic construction for easier handling and mounting.

  • Easy-clean magic

  • Lightweight synthetic construction for easier handling and mounting.

Recreational Enjoyment

Eco-Friendly Living

Time-Saving Convenience

Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle is the market leader for versatile, all-purpose synthetic side saddles, offering an adjustable-fit system and an approachable price that appeals to riding schools and recreational riders. Its quick-fit adjustability gives it a clear technical and financial advantage over fixed-tree models such as the Mayhew and Heritage Craft, making it a cost-effective choice for owners who need one saddle to fit multiple horses.

  • Bold flair

  • Weatherproof build

  • Easy-clean magic

  • Lightweight synthetic construction for easier handling and mounting.

  • Adjustable girthing and billet placement to fit a wide range of horse shapes.

  • Bold flair

  • Weatherproof build

  • Easy-clean magic

  • Lightweight synthetic construction for easier handling and mounting.

  • Adjustable girthing and billet placement to fit a wide range of horse shapes.

Order Now

$800-1300 USD

3
BEST VALUE SIDE-SADDLE

Elan Side Saddle Synthetic Model

Elan Side Saddle Synthetic Model

Elan's Side Saddle Synthetic Model focuses on lightweight, sport-oriented performance with ergonomically sculpted panels that reduce bulk and improve rider close-contact feel. Priced between entry-level training models and premium bespoke saddles, it undercuts handcrafted alternatives like Heritage Craft while delivering technical features aimed at active riders who want better performance than the Whippy training model.

3.8
★★★☆☆

  • Performance fit

  • Ergo seat

  • Performance fit

  • Ergo seat

Review Summary

75%

"The Elan Side Saddle Synthetic Model is seen as an affordable, comfortable option for casual riders, but several long-term users report issues with stitching and girth wear over time."

  • Nimble balance

  • Economical synthetic option ideal for beginners and casual riders.

  • Nimble balance

  • Economical synthetic option ideal for beginners and casual riders.

Enhanced Physical Well-Being

Skill Development & Mastery

Recreational Enjoyment

Elan's Side Saddle Synthetic Model focuses on lightweight, sport-oriented performance with ergonomically sculpted panels that reduce bulk and improve rider close-contact feel. Priced between entry-level training models and premium bespoke saddles, it undercuts handcrafted alternatives like Heritage Craft while delivering technical features aimed at active riders who want better performance than the Whippy training model.

  • Performance fit

  • Ergo seat

  • Nimble balance

  • Economical synthetic option ideal for beginners and casual riders.

  • Padded pommel and knee support that help maintain a secure seat.

  • Performance fit

  • Ergo seat

  • Nimble balance

  • Economical synthetic option ideal for beginners and casual riders.

  • Padded pommel and knee support that help maintain a secure seat.

Order Now

$600-1000 USD

4
BEST SHOW-QUALITY CRAFT

Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle

Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle

Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle blends traditional styling with modern synthetics, targeting buyers who want the classic look without leather upkeep; its hand-finished accents and period-accurate shaping command a higher upfront price but retain strong resale appeal. Technically it emphasizes authenticity and finish over rapid adjustability, so while it rivals Mayhew on build quality it is less flexible than Phoenix Rising for multi-horse use.

4.3
★★★★☆

  • Vintage vibes

  • Modern materials

  • Vintage vibes

  • Modern materials

Review Summary

86%

"Owners like the Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle for its classic styling and solid construction, noting reliable fit and comfort, though a minority experience rub points that require minor adjustments."

  • Sturdy charm

  • Hand-finished styling and attention to traditional detail using synthetic materials.

  • Sturdy charm

  • Hand-finished styling and attention to traditional detail using synthetic materials.

Eco-Friendly Living

Recreational Enjoyment

Enhanced Physical Well-Being

Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle blends traditional styling with modern synthetics, targeting buyers who want the classic look without leather upkeep; its hand-finished accents and period-accurate shaping command a higher upfront price but retain strong resale appeal. Technically it emphasizes authenticity and finish over rapid adjustability, so while it rivals Mayhew on build quality it is less flexible than Phoenix Rising for multi-horse use.

  • Vintage vibes

  • Modern materials

  • Sturdy charm

  • Hand-finished styling and attention to traditional detail using synthetic materials.

  • Deep, formal seat profile suited for side-saddle showing and presentation.

  • Vintage vibes

  • Modern materials

  • Sturdy charm

  • Hand-finished styling and attention to traditional detail using synthetic materials.

  • Deep, formal seat profile suited for side-saddle showing and presentation.

Order Now

$1100-1800 USD

5
BEST TRAINING MODEL

Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model

Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model

The Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model is designed for schools and beginners, emphasizing rugged construction, easy maintenance, and the lowest purchase price in the lineup to withstand heavy use. It forgoes some of the advanced fit and finish found in the Mayhew or Heritage Craft saddles but offers the best financial value for instructional programs and riders starting side-saddle training.

3.9
★★★☆☆

  • Training-perfect

  • Safety-first

  • Training-perfect

  • Safety-first

Review Summary

78%

"The Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model is popular as an entry-level training saddle—stable and easy to mount—but experienced riders call out less refined finish and faster wear on the synthetic cover with heavy use."

  • Adjustable rigging

  • Specifically designed for schooling with extra padding and supportive blocks.

  • Adjustable rigging

  • Specifically designed for schooling with extra padding and supportive blocks.

Skill Development & Mastery

Enhanced Physical Well-Being

Time-Saving Convenience

The Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model is designed for schools and beginners, emphasizing rugged construction, easy maintenance, and the lowest purchase price in the lineup to withstand heavy use. It forgoes some of the advanced fit and finish found in the Mayhew or Heritage Craft saddles but offers the best financial value for instructional programs and riders starting side-saddle training.

  • Training-perfect

  • Safety-first

  • Adjustable rigging

  • Specifically designed for schooling with extra padding and supportive blocks.

  • Robust synthetic construction to withstand frequent use and easy cleaning.

  • Training-perfect

  • Safety-first

  • Adjustable rigging

  • Specifically designed for schooling with extra padding and supportive blocks.

  • Robust synthetic construction to withstand frequent use and easy cleaning.

Order Now

$450-800 USD

What Research and Practical Studies Say About Synthetic Saddles and Fit

A growing body of equine biomechanics and veterinary research highlights how saddle design, fit, and materials influence both horse comfort and rider stability. While much of the literature focuses on general saddle fit, several consistent findings apply to modern synthetic side saddles and their advantages in everyday use.

Pressure mapping and saddle-fit studies show that appropriately shaped panels and adjustable rigging reduce peak pressure points on the horse's back, lowering the risk of soreness and compensatory gait changes.

Biomechanics research indicates that lighter saddles reduce the energy cost of locomotion for both horse and rider, which can be beneficial on long rides and in colder climates where energy conservation matters.

Veterinary case reports and welfare-focused reviews emphasize that good fit and correct rider position — aided by shaped pommels and ergonomic design — improve spinal comfort and reduce the incidence of back pain and muscle tension.

Material science comparisons reveal modern synthetic polymers can match or exceed traditional leather in moisture resistance and ease of cleaning; proper maintenance of synthetic saddles also helps control bacteria and allergens.

Training and safety analyses show that side-saddle-specific features, such as secure thigh rolls, shaped pommels, and adjustable leathers, enhance rider stability and reduce the likelihood of dislodgement during unexpected movements.

In USA, modern synthetic side saddles give riders the historic silhouette they want with practical advantages for our climate and riding styles. The five models featured here — Mayhew Ladies Side Saddle Model 2000, Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle, Elan Side Saddle Synthetic Model, Heritage Craft Synthetic Side Saddle, and Whippy Side Saddle Company Training Model — each balance traditional lines and contemporary fit features in different ways. For most American riders seeking the best mix of safety innovations, weather resistance, and adjustable fit, the Phoenix Rising Synthetic Side Saddle stands out as the top overall choice on this page. We hope you found what you were looking for; use the search or filters to refine by size, discipline, or price to expand or narrow your options.

Discover More
  • All Purpose Synthetic Horse Saddles
  • Trail Synthetic Horse Saddles
  • Training Synthetic Horse Saddles
  • Vaulting Synthetic Horse Saddles
  • Racing Synthetic Horse Saddles

Copyright © 2025 InceptionAi Inc.

Trademark Policy

Articles

About Us

Contact Us

Careers

Sitemap