Loadstar ST205/75D15 Powder Coated White Modular Wheel
The Loadstar ST205/75D15 Powder Coated White Modular Wheel earns best-in-class for balancing affordability with trailer-specific design—its ST-sizing and modular construction suit light-to-medium horse trailers while the white powder coat provides corrosion resistance. Compared with the heavier Martin Wheel and the decorative Americana spoke option, Loadstar offers a lower upfront cost and easier fitment for common ST tires, making it a practical choice for budget-conscious owners who still need trailer-rated durability.
Bright white finish (barn selfie)
Corrosion resistant (salt proof)
Bright white finish (barn selfie)
Corrosion resistant (salt proof)
Review Summary
"Buyers praise the Loadstar ST205/75D15 for its low cost, correct fit and clean powder-coated finish out of the box; long-term users note occasional chipping and surface rust in high-moisture climates after several seasons. Overall customers find it a good value for trailer use but not as durable as premium OEM wheels."
Modular design (easy swap)
15" modular steel wheel sized for ST205/75D15 trailer tires
Modular design (easy swap)
15" modular steel wheel sized for ST205/75D15 trailer tires
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
The Loadstar ST205/75D15 Powder Coated White Modular Wheel earns best-in-class for balancing affordability with trailer-specific design—its ST-sizing and modular construction suit light-to-medium horse trailers while the white powder coat provides corrosion resistance. Compared with the heavier Martin Wheel and the decorative Americana spoke option, Loadstar offers a lower upfront cost and easier fitment for common ST tires, making it a practical choice for budget-conscious owners who still need trailer-rated durability.
Bright white finish (barn selfie)
Corrosion resistant (salt proof)
Modular design (easy swap)
15" modular steel wheel sized for ST205/75D15 trailer tires
White powder-coat finish for basic corrosion resistance and easy cleaning
Bright white finish (barn selfie)
Corrosion resistant (salt proof)
Modular design (easy swap)
15" modular steel wheel sized for ST205/75D15 trailer tires
White powder-coat finish for basic corrosion resistance and easy cleaning
$120-180 USD
Carlisle Radial Trail HD Black Powder Coated Steel Wheel
The Carlisle Radial Trail HD Black Powder Coated Steel Wheel is the market leader for durability and long-term value, featuring reinforced construction and a chip-resistant black powder coat that stands up to road salts and frequent hauling. While it commands a premium over the Loadstar and Taskmaster modular wheels, Carlisle’s higher load ratings and proven longevity can lower lifecycle costs for frequent haulers of horse trailers compared with lighter or more decorative options like the Americana spoke wheel.
Matte black finish (stealthy look)
Heavy-duty build (trail tough)
Matte black finish (stealthy look)
Heavy-duty build (trail tough)
Review Summary
"The Carlisle Radial Trail HD black powder-coated steel wheel is frequently reported as rugged with a good factory finish and proper fit for trailers, with many owners satisfied by its resistance to road damage. A minority report minor finish imperfections or curb rash after heavy use, but overall reliability is rated high."
Reinforced rim (rock bouncer)
Robust steel construction with black powder coat designed for trail use
Reinforced rim (rock bouncer)
Robust steel construction with black powder coat designed for trail use
Recreational Enjoyment
Eco-Friendly Living
Time-Saving Convenience
The Carlisle Radial Trail HD Black Powder Coated Steel Wheel is the market leader for durability and long-term value, featuring reinforced construction and a chip-resistant black powder coat that stands up to road salts and frequent hauling. While it commands a premium over the Loadstar and Taskmaster modular wheels, Carlisle’s higher load ratings and proven longevity can lower lifecycle costs for frequent haulers of horse trailers compared with lighter or more decorative options like the Americana spoke wheel.
Matte black finish (stealthy look)
Heavy-duty build (trail tough)
Reinforced rim (rock bouncer)
Robust steel construction with black powder coat designed for trail use
Sized to accept common trailer tire profiles and withstand trailer loads
Matte black finish (stealthy look)
Heavy-duty build (trail tough)
Reinforced rim (rock bouncer)
Robust steel construction with black powder coat designed for trail use
Sized to accept common trailer tire profiles and withstand trailer loads
$140-210 USD
Americana Tire 15x6 Silver Powder Coated Spoke Wheel
The Americana Tire 15x6 Silver Powder Coated Spoke Wheel is targeted at owners who want trailer-rated functionality with a more finished appearance; its silver spoke styling improves curb appeal without sacrificing the corrosion protection of powder coating. Technically it’s less heavy-duty than the Martin Wheel or Carlisle HD options, but it typically comes at a mid-range price and is a good financial compromise for recreational horse trailers where style and occasional use matter more than maximum load capacity.
Silver spoke style (retro chic)
Lightweight assembly (fleet friendly)
Silver spoke style (retro chic)
Lightweight assembly (fleet friendly)
Review Summary
"The Americana 15x6 silver spoke-style powder coated wheel gets compliments for its attractive appearance and straightforward mounting, though some users occasionally experienced slight balance issues or early chips on the finish. Most reviewers consider it a solid mid-range choice for trailers wanting a nicer look without OEM pricing."
Polish guard (shine longer)
15x6 silver powder-coated spoke design for a more finished trailer look
Polish guard (shine longer)
15x6 silver powder-coated spoke design for a more finished trailer look
Recreational Enjoyment
The Americana Tire 15x6 Silver Powder Coated Spoke Wheel is targeted at owners who want trailer-rated functionality with a more finished appearance; its silver spoke styling improves curb appeal without sacrificing the corrosion protection of powder coating. Technically it’s less heavy-duty than the Martin Wheel or Carlisle HD options, but it typically comes at a mid-range price and is a good financial compromise for recreational horse trailers where style and occasional use matter more than maximum load capacity.
Silver spoke style (retro chic)
Lightweight assembly (fleet friendly)
Polish guard (shine longer)
15x6 silver powder-coated spoke design for a more finished trailer look
Steel build with protective coating to reduce rust on exposed spokes
Silver spoke style (retro chic)
Lightweight assembly (fleet friendly)
Polish guard (shine longer)
15x6 silver powder-coated spoke design for a more finished trailer look
Steel build with protective coating to reduce rust on exposed spokes
$130-200 USD
Martin Wheel 16x6 Heavy Duty Powder Coated Steel Trailer Wheel
The Martin Wheel 16x6 Heavy Duty Powder Coated Steel Trailer Wheel stands out for heavy-duty applications, offering a larger 16x6 footprint and higher load capacity ideal for larger or multi-horse trailers; its robust construction and premium powder coat are engineered to reduce downtime and replacement frequency. Although its unit price is higher than the narrower ST modular wheels like Loadstar and Taskmaster, the long-term savings in service and higher payload capability make it the best choice when strength and trailer safety are the primary priorities.
16x6 heavy-duty (payload pro)
Thick powder coat (chip-resistant)
16x6 heavy-duty (payload pro)
Thick powder coat (chip-resistant)
Review Summary
"Martin Wheel 16x6 heavy-duty powder-coated steel wheels are widely praised for exceptional build quality, long-lasting finish and correct fitment on commercial and heavy-use trailers; long-term users report minimal corrosion and consistent durability. It is consistently regarded as a market-leading, heavy-duty option."
High-load rating (hauls easily)
16x6 heavy-duty steel wheel engineered for higher load capacities
High-load rating (hauls easily)
16x6 heavy-duty steel wheel engineered for higher load capacities
Time-Saving Convenience
Eco-Friendly Living
Recreational Enjoyment
The Martin Wheel 16x6 Heavy Duty Powder Coated Steel Trailer Wheel stands out for heavy-duty applications, offering a larger 16x6 footprint and higher load capacity ideal for larger or multi-horse trailers; its robust construction and premium powder coat are engineered to reduce downtime and replacement frequency. Although its unit price is higher than the narrower ST modular wheels like Loadstar and Taskmaster, the long-term savings in service and higher payload capability make it the best choice when strength and trailer safety are the primary priorities.
16x6 heavy-duty (payload pro)
Thick powder coat (chip-resistant)
High-load rating (hauls easily)
16x6 heavy-duty steel wheel engineered for higher load capacities
Thicker steel and premium powder-coat for enhanced durability and corrosion resistance
16x6 heavy-duty (payload pro)
Thick powder coat (chip-resistant)
High-load rating (hauls easily)
16x6 heavy-duty steel wheel engineered for higher load capacities
Thicker steel and premium powder-coat for enhanced durability and corrosion resistance
$200-320 USD
Taskmaster ST225/75R15 White Powder Coated Steel Mod Wheel
The Taskmaster ST225/75R15 White Powder Coated Steel Mod Wheel delivers a strong value proposition by combining a wider ST225 fitment with economical pricing and proven powder coat protection for horse trailers. It sits between the smaller Loadstar and the heavy-duty Martin Wheel in terms of load capacity—offering a practical upgrade for owners needing greater load margin without the cost of a full heavy-duty wheel like the Carlisle or Martin options.
Wide profile (stability king)
White mod design (show-ready)
Wide profile (stability king)
White mod design (show-ready)
Review Summary
"Taskmaster ST225/75R15 white powder-coated modular wheels are noted for their affordability and acceptable fit, with many owners happy for occasional towing and light-duty trailer use; however, several long-term reviewers observed the finish can wear or chip sooner than higher-end wheels. Buyers cite good value but not top-tier longevity."
Durable coating (low upkeep)
Modular white steel wheel sized to fit ST225/75R15 trailer tires
Durable coating (low upkeep)
Modular white steel wheel sized to fit ST225/75R15 trailer tires
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
The Taskmaster ST225/75R15 White Powder Coated Steel Mod Wheel delivers a strong value proposition by combining a wider ST225 fitment with economical pricing and proven powder coat protection for horse trailers. It sits between the smaller Loadstar and the heavy-duty Martin Wheel in terms of load capacity—offering a practical upgrade for owners needing greater load margin without the cost of a full heavy-duty wheel like the Carlisle or Martin options.
Wide profile (stability king)
White mod design (show-ready)
Durable coating (low upkeep)
Modular white steel wheel sized to fit ST225/75R15 trailer tires
Powder-coated finish to protect against road salt and weather exposure
Wide profile (stability king)
White mod design (show-ready)
Durable coating (low upkeep)
Modular white steel wheel sized to fit ST225/75R15 trailer tires
Powder-coated finish to protect against road salt and weather exposure
$130-200 USD