Sperry Top-Sider Billfish 3-Eye
The Sperry Top-Sider Billfish 3-Eye is a market-leading, heritage boat shoe that pairs full-grain leather with Sperry’s signature siped non-marking outsole to deliver reliable wet traction and long-term durability. It holds its place for anglers who want a dressier, longer-lasting deck shoe—trading the full waterproofing and extreme slip-resistance of XTRATUF or the technical angling features of Simms for premium leather longevity and classic style at a mid-to-high price point.
Superior wet grip
Breathable canvas
Superior wet grip
Breathable canvas
Review Summary
"Classic, comfortable boat shoe with good everyday traction and style; holds up well for casual fishing and boating but some users report quicker wear and less grip on very slick wet decks."
Iconic 3-eye swagger
Traditional 3-eye moccasin silhouette with marine-grade leather for durability.
Iconic 3-eye swagger
Traditional 3-eye moccasin silhouette with marine-grade leather for durability.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Recreational Enjoyment
The Sperry Top-Sider Billfish 3-Eye is a market-leading, heritage boat shoe that pairs full-grain leather with Sperry’s signature siped non-marking outsole to deliver reliable wet traction and long-term durability. It holds its place for anglers who want a dressier, longer-lasting deck shoe—trading the full waterproofing and extreme slip-resistance of XTRATUF or the technical angling features of Simms for premium leather longevity and classic style at a mid-to-high price point.
Superior wet grip
Breathable canvas
Iconic 3-eye swagger
Traditional 3-eye moccasin silhouette with marine-grade leather for durability.
Non-marking, siped rubber outsole designed for reliable wet traction.
Superior wet grip
Breathable canvas
Iconic 3-eye swagger
Traditional 3-eye moccasin silhouette with marine-grade leather for durability.
Non-marking, siped rubber outsole designed for reliable wet traction.
$110-150 USD
Columbia Bahama Vent PFG
The Columbia Bahama Vent PFG is an affordable, highly ventilated fishing deck shoe designed around breathability and quick-dry comfort with mesh vents and a treatment to resist stains and moisture. It represents the best value in warm conditions, undercutting premium leather and specialty models on price while offering better airflow than Sperry and a lighter, more breathable feel than the heavier XTRATUF workhorses.
Quick-dry mesh
Plush midsole comfort
Quick-dry mesh
Plush midsole comfort
Review Summary
"Lightweight, breathable and comfortable for long days on the water with a reliable non-marking sole; some users wish for more aggressive traction on very slippery surfaces."
PFG ventilated breeze
Lightweight mesh and perforated upper for excellent ventilation and quick drying.
PFG ventilated breeze
Lightweight mesh and perforated upper for excellent ventilation and quick drying.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Recreational Enjoyment
Time-Saving Convenience
The Columbia Bahama Vent PFG is an affordable, highly ventilated fishing deck shoe designed around breathability and quick-dry comfort with mesh vents and a treatment to resist stains and moisture. It represents the best value in warm conditions, undercutting premium leather and specialty models on price while offering better airflow than Sperry and a lighter, more breathable feel than the heavier XTRATUF workhorses.
Quick-dry mesh
Plush midsole comfort
PFG ventilated breeze
Lightweight mesh and perforated upper for excellent ventilation and quick drying.
Comfortable EVA midsole with moderate arch support for long days on the water.
Quick-dry mesh
Plush midsole comfort
PFG ventilated breeze
Lightweight mesh and perforated upper for excellent ventilation and quick drying.
Comfortable EVA midsole with moderate arch support for long days on the water.
$80-120 USD
XTRATUF Sharkbyte Deck Shoe
The XTRATUF Sharkbyte Deck Shoe is built for uncompromising slip resistance and near-water durability, featuring a sticky, non-slip sole and synthetic upper engineered for quick drainage and rugged, long-term performance. Positioned as the workhorse for commercial and serious recreational fishermen, it offers superior traction and protection compared with the more lifestyle-focused Sperry and the ventilated, budget-friendly Columbia—typically commanding a higher price that reflects its heavy-duty construction.
All-weather grip
Neoprene sock comfort
All-weather grip
Neoprene sock comfort
Review Summary
"Praised for outstanding marine traction, durability and a secure fit, making it a favorite among frequent anglers; a minority of buyers note breathability concerns and a premium price."
Sharkbyte toughness
Durable, oil- and slip-resistant outsole formulated for aggressive wet traction.
Sharkbyte toughness
Durable, oil- and slip-resistant outsole formulated for aggressive wet traction.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Recreational Enjoyment
The XTRATUF Sharkbyte Deck Shoe is built for uncompromising slip resistance and near-water durability, featuring a sticky, non-slip sole and synthetic upper engineered for quick drainage and rugged, long-term performance. Positioned as the workhorse for commercial and serious recreational fishermen, it offers superior traction and protection compared with the more lifestyle-focused Sperry and the ventilated, budget-friendly Columbia—typically commanding a higher price that reflects its heavy-duty construction.
All-weather grip
Neoprene sock comfort
Sharkbyte toughness
Durable, oil- and slip-resistant outsole formulated for aggressive wet traction.
Quick-drying synthetic upper with reinforced toe for abrasion resistance.
All-weather grip
Neoprene sock comfort
Sharkbyte toughness
Durable, oil- and slip-resistant outsole formulated for aggressive wet traction.
Quick-drying synthetic upper with reinforced toe for abrasion resistance.
$150-220 USD
Helly Hansen Watermoc 5
The Helly Hansen Watermoc 5 is a lightweight, Scandinavian-designed slip-on that emphasizes fast drying and functional deck traction with a molded EVA sole and a weather-resistant upper. It occupies a middle ground between style and utility by offering an affordable, low-profile alternative with solid grip and easy on/off convenience, making it a good choice for anglers who prioritize packability and quick comfort rather than full waterproofing.
Waterproof slip-on
Featherlight feel
Waterproof slip-on
Featherlight feel
Review Summary
"Easy to slip on, comfortable and drains well for wet conditions; some users report the sole wears faster than higher-end options and find sizing inconsistent."
Moccasin ease
Minimalist, water-friendly upper built for easy drainage and fast drying.
Moccasin ease
Minimalist, water-friendly upper built for easy drainage and fast drying.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Time-Saving Convenience
Recreational Enjoyment
The Helly Hansen Watermoc 5 is a lightweight, Scandinavian-designed slip-on that emphasizes fast drying and functional deck traction with a molded EVA sole and a weather-resistant upper. It occupies a middle ground between style and utility by offering an affordable, low-profile alternative with solid grip and easy on/off convenience, making it a good choice for anglers who prioritize packability and quick comfort rather than full waterproofing.
Waterproof slip-on
Featherlight feel
Moccasin ease
Minimalist, water-friendly upper built for easy drainage and fast drying.
Flexible, grippy outsole engineered for multidirectional wet traction.
Waterproof slip-on
Featherlight feel
Moccasin ease
Minimalist, water-friendly upper built for easy drainage and fast drying.
Flexible, grippy outsole engineered for multidirectional wet traction.
$120-170 USD
Simms Currents Fishing Shoe
The Simms Currents Fishing Shoe is a purpose-built angling shoe focused on performance features like quick-drain mesh, sticky rubber outsoles and a secure, foot-hugging fit for casting and light wading. As the specialist option in this list, it sacrifices some of the casual styling of Sperry and the lower price of Columbia for targeted technical advantages—commanding a premium but delivering superior on-water functionality for dedicated fishermen.
Superior drainage
Sticky rubber traction
Superior drainage
Sticky rubber traction
Review Summary
"Sturdy, quick-drying fishing shoe with excellent grip and build quality suited to heavy use; priced at a premium and a few users report a stiff break-in or narrow fit."
Performance-driven fit
Technical construction combining quick-dry materials and reinforced support zones.
Performance-driven fit
Technical construction combining quick-dry materials and reinforced support zones.
Enhanced Physical Well-Being
Skill Development & Mastery
Recreational Enjoyment
The Simms Currents Fishing Shoe is a purpose-built angling shoe focused on performance features like quick-drain mesh, sticky rubber outsoles and a secure, foot-hugging fit for casting and light wading. As the specialist option in this list, it sacrifices some of the casual styling of Sperry and the lower price of Columbia for targeted technical advantages—commanding a premium but delivering superior on-water functionality for dedicated fishermen.
Superior drainage
Sticky rubber traction
Performance-driven fit
Technical construction combining quick-dry materials and reinforced support zones.
High-performance outsole offering superior slip resistance and durability.
Superior drainage
Sticky rubber traction
Performance-driven fit
Technical construction combining quick-dry materials and reinforced support zones.
High-performance outsole offering superior slip resistance and durability.
$200-260 USD